2024 - Aleshia Skyes (Dunbar) - Commonwealth League 2024 - Dominique Gibbons (Collegiate) - Metro League 2023 - Kristen Parker (Mercy) - Metro League
2022 - Kayla Bohn (Oldham County) - Metro League
2021 - Patrick McAnulty (Kentucky Country Day) - Metro League
2020 - N/A
2019 - Bob Newton (South Oldham) - Metro League
2018 - Patrick McAnulty (Kentucky Country Day) - Metro League
2017 - James Conklin (Oldham County) and Rylee Huffman (Eastern High School) - Metro League
2016 - Jimmy Mitchell (Notre Dame Academy) - Metro League
2015 - Rylee Huffman (Eastern High School) - Metro League
2014 - Jason Curran (Assumption High School) - Metro League
2013 - Patrick McAnulty (Kentucky Country Day) - Metro League
2012 - Dean Walker (Eastern - Division II) - Metro League
2011 - Brandon Davis (Sacred Heart Academy) - Metro League
2010 - Patrick McAnulty (Kentucky Country Day) - Metro League
2009 -  N/A
2008 -  N/A
2007 - Patrick McAnulty (Kentucky Country Day) - Metro League
2006 - N/A
2005 - N/A

*From 2005-2012, the Kentucky Lacrosse Association (KLA) was the governing body for girls lacrosse in Kentucky and thus administered this award.